Classic Home-Style Mexican Soups in Mexico City - Culinary Backstreets | Culinary Backstreets
Sign up with email


Already a member? Log in.

Trouble logging in?

Not a member? Sign up!

We grew up in a household where drinking soup directly from the bowl was frowned upon, done only surreptitiously when Mom was looking away or as an act of impish rebellion, a bold unshackling from the spoon and its torment.

Yet it took little prodding from Isis Iturriaga, founder and proprietor of Sanadoras La Caldería, to lift our earthenware bowl with both hands to eager lips and down the last of our impeccable caldo de hongos (mushroom soup) in three great gulps.

“You are in your home,” she reiterated as the chipotle-infused liquid began to spark our insides. This is her mantra for the place, a plinth at the core of her being.

More a command than suggestion, there’s something of left-handed magic at work when she speaks it, something of the iron will woven into Sanadoras – an audacious experiment in social responsibility and Slow Food built upon a quintet of classic home-style Mexican soups. (Two are beef-based, two chicken-based and then there is the vegan mushroom soup.)

Isis, who formerly worked in set construction for theater, film and other large-scale projects, opened the place in August 2015 as something of a vision quest. “I think it’s one of those 40s things – change of life, of destiny, you know, all of that madness, I just said ‘I’m going to open my caldería,’” she explained.

After scouting locations in the capital’s hipster corridors of Roma and Navarte, where options were expensive yet small, she heard about a large property available on Fray Servando in the Merced neighborhood and decided to check it out.

“When I got there I told myself, ‘This is it,’” Isis said.

With seating in the atrium and an adjacent room, the caldería serves as anchor to an ever-evolving menagerie of microbusinesses – a mezcalería, a pulque bar, a chocolatería, a barbershop, a thrift shop and, on the upper levels, various workshops used by artists and creative types for cultural production. “It’s a project of projects,” she said.

For Isis, the caldería serves as an exercise in cultural responsibility, one that’s infused with Slow Food principles. All of the meat and other ingredients are sourced locally from nearby markets, always fresh and never packaged or frozen. Conveniently, the sprawling Merced Market is just a few blocks away.

She noted that no plastic, Styrofoam or napkins are used, and that if we wanted a second soup to take home, we’d have to come up with our own container, which we promptly ventured out to buy.

Isis added that she casts a wide net and focuses on underrepresented communities when it comes to staffing – the women in her kitchen include some who are indigenous and speak little to no Spanish, one with nine children and another who was a former convict.

On our foray into the kitchen, a few of the ladies scattered when they saw our camera, breaking into laughter. One of the brave ones, Isabel, an elderly but vibrant woman was game, pulling Martina, another cook, into frame – or attempting to anyway. Chatting with us while cleaning up, they were genuinely enthused about the chance to work at the restaurant, adding that they believe the project does a lot of good.

It seems no coincidence that Sanadoras, which means “healers” in Spanish, is located a stone’s throw from Mexico City’s witchcraft market – the Mercado Sonora, a one-stop shop for all things magical. Shamans, fortune tellers, healers, herbalists and, of course, brujas and brujos (witches and warlocks) are on standby for all your ritual and spell-casting needs.

For us, Sonora is creepy, not least because of the exotic animal trade that takes place in the market. A nice hot bowl of soup at Sanadoras – a different type of potion to ease the soul – sounds just about right to shake off any lingering chill from the dark vibe at Sonora.

“It’s about coming home,” Isis said, “It’s the food from our mothers.”

Mexican caldos, it must be noted, can be labor intensive. Here veggies are typically chopped into large chunks made for multiple bites; beef can come in fist-sized hunks; and chicken legs go in whole, skin, gristle and all. With this kind of preparation, there is no doubt the meat is real and unprocessed, and that human hands cut every carrot, every potato.

“It’s slow food, take it or leave it.”

While fork and knife might seem an effective angle of attack at the outset, veterans manage brilliantly with only a spoon in one hand and a corn tortilla in the other. If you find this tricky, let others lead by example.

On this most recent visit, we tried using the tortillas that come with the caldo de hongos, which featured a mix of white and oyster mushrooms (the latter, known as setas locally, are vital to the composition of a traditional Mexican mushroom soup), to thin out the herd of ingredients a bit.

Isis explained that their tortillas are the real deal, that is to say they undergo the process known as nixtamalization, where the corn grains are soaked and heated in an alkaline solution, traditionally limewater, before being washed, hulled, ground and made into tortillas. The process, a brilliant pre-Hispanic technology from Mesoamerica, greatly enhances both the nutritional value of the corn and the aroma, while reducing fungal toxins. It’s also, sadly, becoming a rarity in Mexico, with households, street vendors and fondas often opting to use cheap, processed alternatives.

With the large chunks mostly polished off, we washed down the last layer of liquid from the bowl – the broth tasted strongly of the seasonings, in this case a blend of chiles and spices, rather than salt, an outcome that relies on fresh ingredients and patient preparation. Our core was warm, our face sweating, and we were on the whole quite satisfied.

Before leaving, we ordered the caldo mole de olla, one of the two beef options (the puchero being the other), to go for our evening meal. The most popular option at the restaurant, the mole de olla has a rich, thick broth that offers a slow but never overwhelming heat. The freshness of the carrots and potatoes came through with the taste, and the veggies were cooked evenly, soft but firm. Likewise, the stewed beef was buttery, and beyond some gristle and fat, the meat yielded nicely to the bite.

Isis’ favorite, however, is the caldo grosero, one of two chicken soups. (The other poultry option, the caldo tlapeño, is similar but with a bit more heat, making it a good hangover cure.) All five options are generously portioned and incredibly affordable at just 60 pesos (US$3) per bowl.

Drinks are similarly inexpensive; a cup of one of the various aguas frescas, water infused with fruit, flowers, spices or even vegetables, is 20 pesos and comes with free refills (an unusual perk).

Isis told us that the place sees a broad range of clientele, including visiting foreigners and office workers that crowd in for the weekday comida (lunch) rush. Yet the spot’s popularity has led to grumbling about long wait times and slow service. “It’s slow food, take it or leave it,” Isis answered plainly when we asked her about it.

She pointed out that space is limited and most customers do not complain, even when lines form out to the sidewalk. Those impatient souls who do kick up a fuss are missing the point of the experience, she explained.

“We would rather lose a bad customer than not maintain what we are,” Isis told us defiantly. Real soup takes time to consume and should never be rushed.

  • BangganeApril 5, 2019 Banggane (0)
    Editor’s note: We regret to report that Banggane has closed. The weather prompted us […] Posted in Queens
  • Kondo HontenSeptember 20, 2022 Kondo Honten (0)
    Japan is well known for its variety of national dishes, as well as local specialties […] Posted in Tokyo
  • Homestead Gourmet ShopNovember 23, 2021 Homestead Gourmet Shop (0)
    Homestead Gourmet Shop in Kew Gardens, with its quaint, peeling sign and cheery […] Posted in Queens
James Young

Published on March 11, 2019

Related stories

April 5, 2019

Banggane: In Goat They Trust

Queens | By Dave Cook
By Dave Cook
QueensEditor’s note: We regret to report that Banggane has closed. The weather prompted us to order as much as we did. Winter was chilling us to the bone on our first visit, several years ago, to Banggane (Bahn-gah-Nay). This Korean restaurant in Murray Hill sits on a wide-open stretch of Northern Boulevard that’s particularly exposed…
September 20, 2022

Kondo Honten: Simple Pleasures

Tokyo | By Davey Young
By Davey Young
TokyoJapan is well known for its variety of national dishes, as well as local specialties claimed by individual regions and cities. Tokyo, which boasts more Michelin stars than any city in the world, is a natural nexus for these disparate eats, as well as more international fare. It may come as a surprise, then, that…
November 23, 2021

Homestead Gourmet Shop: German Time Capsule

Queens | By Ike Allen
By Ike Allen
QueensHomestead Gourmet Shop in Kew Gardens, with its quaint, peeling sign and cheery strudel-filled front window, looks like a Disney vision of the Old World. Its employees, clad in all white with old-fashioned paper hats, evoke a 1950s soda fountain shop. It feels like a relic in a forgotten corner of the city. In fact,…
Select your currency
USD United States (US) dollar
EUR Euro