The Secret to a Guidebook Favorite in Shanghai | Culinary Backstreets
Sign up with email


Already a member? Log in.

Trouble logging in?

Not a member? Sign up!

Ask a Shanghainese person for the best běnbāng, or local, restaurant in town, and you’ll probably be pointed toward Old Jesse. The doyenne of haipai cuisine, this ramshackle restaurant is the darling of the guidebook industry, with mentions in publications from Travel + Leisure to Lonely Planet, but that doesn’t mean that it’s foreigner-friendly. In fact, when LP first published their listing back in 2008, Old Jesse stopped taking reservations in English for some time, just to spite the hordes of tourists vying for a seat in their tiny former French Concession establishment. Even now, the lingua franca in the packed dining room is Shanghainese, and it’s still not uncommon for a laowai’s reservations to disappear if he or she is just a few minutes late, or for foreigners to have to watch hungrily as the dishes they ordered come out to tables manned by locals first, even though said locals were seated long after them.

You can’t really blame the staff at Jesse. What looks like xenophobia is really just good business sense; they’re weeding out the less lucrative guests with that age-old ploy: rudeness. With only about ten tables in the whole two-floor extended living room, plus an added side room with a separate entrance (where they often stick the white faces), they have to maximize their cramped real estate to stay afloat. Rents on the sleepy, tree-lined street aren’t cheap, especially with former President Jiang Zemin rumored to be living just around the corner, and foreigners just don’t order like Chinese diners do. Table for two? Sure, they’ve got one, but if you sit two Shanghainese diners there, you won’t even be able to see the tablecloth for all the dishes. For many foreigners, ordering a few items off the chef’s recommendations page is plenty.

Old Jesse's chicken soup, photo by UnTour ShanghaiIf you want to experience Old Jesse like the locals, the key to getting past all that prejudice is to order like a pro. Go big or go home. This is not a waste-not-want-not dinner, and it works best with big groups, so cobble together a group of hungry friends. Start the process before you even walk under the old-timey wooden sign by calling ahead and reserving a couple of the specialty dishes only available by advanced order (or having your concierge help you out). The little bit of local knowledge will earn you the respect that attempts at Mandarin won’t. Here’s your cheatsheet:

Opium Fish Head (葱烤鱼头, Cōngkǎo yútóu)
You’ll smell this one before you see it. The waiter pulls back a tangled mess of fragrant grilled scallions to reveal an entire codfish head before diners descend on the luscious cheeks. Have your chopsticks at the ready because there’s limited supply and high demand for the white meat hidden beneath the scales.

Eight Treasure Pig Trotter/Duck (八宝猪手/鸭, bābǎo zhūshǒu/yā)
In both versions of this treasured dish the meat is deboned, then restuffed with glutinous rice, chestnuts, mushrooms, cured ham and more, then braised in a thickened sweet glaze. We prefer the unctuously rich trotter for its fatty pork skin, but if you make it back a second time, the duck is worth ordering as well.

Red-Braised Pork Shank (红烧蹄膀, hóngshāo tí pang)
Behind xiǎolóngbāo (soup dumplings), red-braised pork belly is Shanghai’s second-most famous dish. This version substitutes the fatty cut for a bone-in shoulder. To melt the muscle, it’s slow-cooked for hours, a technique that helps pull marrow out of the bone and adds it to the thickened soy-fermented bean paste sauce. And the marbled belly that turns off some picky eaters isn’t visible (but please, if you do order the hongshao rou, don’t discard the fat!).

Chicken Soup (鸡炖汤, jī dùntāng)
Double-boiled and floating with red dates, the soup is served last, as is typical of most Chinese meals. There’s a whole chicken in the bottom of the earthenware pot, but really that’s just to flavor the glossy, super-concentrated chicken stock. If you feel a throat tickle coming on, you might as well go ahead and preorder this Chinese version of Jewish penicillin for the next day.

  • February 7, 2015 First Stop (0)
    Editor’s note: For the latest installment in our series First Stop, we asked Fuchsia […] Posted in Shanghai
  • March 3, 2014 Elixir Health Pot (0)
    Healthy hotpot sounds like a contradiction in terms, which is probably why Elixir […] Posted in Shanghai
  • June 24, 2013 Ding Te Le (0)
    For a Chinese city as fast-paced and increasingly cosmopolitan as Shanghai, there are […] Posted in Shanghai

Related stories

February 7, 2015

First Stop: Fuchsia Dunlop's Shanghai

Shanghai | By Winnie Yang
By Winnie Yang
ShanghaiEditor’s note: For the latest installment in our series First Stop, we asked Fuchsia Dunlop where she stops first for food when she heads to Shanghai. Dunlop is a cook and food writer specializing in Chinese cuisine. She is the author of four books, including, most recently, Every Grain of Rice: Simple Chinese Home Cooking. She has…
March 3, 2014

Elixir Health Pot: Hot Tonic

Shanghai | By Jamie Barys
By Jamie Barys
ShanghaiHealthy hotpot sounds like a contradiction in terms, which is probably why Elixir doesn’t even use “hotpot” in its name. Instead it labels itself “health pot” in English, or无老锅 (wúlǎoguō - “No Aging Pot”) in Chinese. Its fountain-of-youth claims are touted by celebrities across Asia, from Mando-Pop’s reigning dancing queen Jolin Tsai to K-Pop crossover…
June 24, 2013

Ding Te Le: The Late-Night Noodle Oasis

Shanghai | By Kyle Long
By Kyle Long
ShanghaiFor a Chinese city as fast-paced and increasingly cosmopolitan as Shanghai, there are surprisingly few late-night dining options that don’t involve ordering from the roving, streetside pushcarts that hawk grilled skewers or fried rice and noodles. Unfortunately, these midnight vendors are not always where you want them to be when you need them most, after…
Select your currency
USD United States (US) dollar
EUR Euro