“The people with permits, they are not working. We vendors on the streets, we need more permits,” yelled Mehdi, a New York street vendor of Bengali origin, at a recent protest for more permits. Street vending in the city – in particular food vending – is largely the domain of immigrants like Mehdi, seemingly an easy way to start earning an income.

But selling food from a street cart is no easy ride. Sean Basinski, Director of the Street Vendor Project, which advocates on behalf of street-based sellers, says food vendor licenses are relatively easy and inexpensive to acquire. There is no cap on the number of food licenses issued. There’s a catch, though. To sell food, in addition to a food license you must also acquire a permit for the food cart. But the number of permits allowed across the five boroughs has been capped at 3,000 since 1981. It can take up to 30 years for a food permit to become available.

The permit wait list opens up infrequently, usually due to political pressure. This last happened in 2004, when the city decided to do a lottery for the few available permits. Luis Alfonso Marin, a Colombian arepa vendor in Queens, recounted that “for 16 years I had to hustle to make a living without the protection of a permit.”

Consequently, the sale of permits today takes place primarily on the black market – version of the “padrone” or contract labor system that existed at the turn of the 20th century. Currently, the normally $200 permit can go for up to $25,000 on the black market. “We have two choices: to sell illegally or enter the black market,” Muhammad Attia, another street vendor activist, says. “We want to work legally, give us more permits.” Vendors, activists and their allies across New York City are calling for an increase in the number of permits allowed – the Lift the Caps! Campaign.

Whether anything will change is now up to the 51 New York City Council members. Rumor has it that a draft bill addressing New York street vendors’ demands is making the rounds.

(Additional funding for this piece was provided by the Buenas Obras Fund)

  • November 10, 2014 Şiraz (0)
    Even we sometimes find that our palates have grown weary of rakı and eggplant salad. […] Posted in Istanbul
  • Top 5 French Concession Noodle JointsSeptember 17, 2018 Top 5 French Concession Noodle Joints (0)
    The relative abundance of heritage architecture and mixed zoning in the former French […] Posted in Shanghai
  • Cairo RestaurantJuly 19, 2019 Cairo Restaurant (1)
    Like many other Egyptians, when Cairo Restaurant owner Magdy Hegad talks about khushari, […] Posted in Istanbul
Sarah Khan

Published on August 12, 2016

Related stories

November 10, 2014

Şiraz: From Iran, with Love

Istanbul | By Roxanne Darrow
IstanbulEven we sometimes find that our palates have grown weary of rakı and eggplant salad. Lately, when that happens, we’ve been heading over to the Asian side of Istanbul for unique Iranian-Turkish mezes and hearty carafes of Aegean red wine at Şiraz, a tiny meyhane in the Moda neighborhood of Kadıköy. Opened two years ago…
best noodles former french concession
September 17, 2018

Top 5 French Concession Noodle Joints

Shanghai | By Kyle Long
ShanghaiThe relative abundance of heritage architecture and mixed zoning in the former French Concession neighborhood (technically the Xuhui district) has left a legacy of nooks and crannies where a number of mom-and-pop noodle shops are able to withstand the test of time and pressures of a fast-changing economy. Luckily, enough noodle lovers are still craving…
Cairo Restaurant, photo by Zeyad Abouzeid
July 19, 2019

Cairo Restaurant: Eat Like an Egyptian

Istanbul | By Geoffrey Ballinger
IstanbulLike many other Egyptians, when Cairo Restaurant owner Magdy Hegad talks about khushari, his eyes glisten with an emotion akin to love – but when he talks about seafood, the glisten is elevated to something closer to religious fervor. “We do it differently,” he explains. “Just try it, and you will see.” We first ventured…