Editor’s note: We regret to report that İstiridye Balık Lokantası has closed.

These days, writing about Istanbul’s old-school restaurants can be heartbreaking work. No sooner do we find out about a classic lunch spot than it turns out the place is about to be closed down to make way for yet another development project. Meanwhile, Istanbul’s relentless drive to modernize and “clean up” its streets has meant there is less and less room for traditional food vendors to operate. We weren’t surprised to learn that one of our favorite street food sellers, the bespectacled man who provided freshly peeled cucumbers by the Galata Tower, recently gave up his iconic perch after being relentlessly squeezed by the municipal authorities.

We were fully prepared, then, to be heartbroken yet again when we found İstiridye Balık Lokantası, a venerable fish restaurant, no longer at its decades-old location on Mumhane Caddesi, a street in the waterfront Karaköy area that has so many good restaurants along it that it acts as a kind of a culinary vortex, radiating a magnetic pull that we find hard to resist.

Fortunately, it turned out to be a false alarm. Rather than closed, the 80-year-old İstiridye had simply moved down the street. While the new space is smaller and brighter, lacking the clubby aura that the previous dark-wood-paneled location exuded, the dedicated clientele remains the same: a lunchtime crowd of local office workers and executives with exacting tastes. Karaköy, once a busy port area, remains a mostly commercial zone (though one that’s increasingly home to new galleries and hip cafes), with elegant buildings housing shipping and holding companies. The people who come to İstiridye expect the restaurant to serve food whose quality is consistent, because, it would appear, many of them seem to come here every day.

Even better, the simple menu and the staff – serious-faced waiters in crimson vests and crisp ties who hustle from table to table – have not changed. The chowder-like fish soup (delicious) is still on offer, as is the small assortment of fresh fish, most of them – perhaps so that the busy customers don’t have to work too hard to eat their lunch – deboned, skewered with green pepper and onion and grilled over coals.

We opted for the dil şiş, thin strips of flounder that are rolled up and grilled on a skewer. The fish was superb, the outside of the fillets slightly charred and crisp, the inside moist and tender. The table next to us ordered levrek şiş, large chunks of sea bass fillets that were also skewered and grilled, and which also looked very tasty.

We finished our meal off with nothing more than a simple glass of tea, pondering the tremendous amount of change all around us. Down the street, excavators were busy digging a big pit that appeared destined to be a new high-rise, while a few doors down a narrow Ottoman-era house, long unoccupied, had been turned into a four-story boutique selling handmade jewelry and designer clothes. İstiridye’s new digs may be without the same old-fashioned charm as its former spot, but in today’s Istanbul, even a move down the street can be considered permanence.

The original version of this review was published on Istanbul Eats on March 8, 2010.

  • PortoJanuary 7, 2020 Porto (0)
    Lunch at Casa Guedes is one of our favorite culinary rituals in Porto: After snagging a […] Posted in Porto
  • Emice’nin YeriNovember 27, 2017 Emice’nin Yeri (0)
    Everyone seems to feel at ease in Emice’nin Yeri. It’s the kind of place where workers […] Posted in Istanbul
  • May 20, 2014 Santa Filomena (0)
    Like the classic optical illusion of the faces and the vase, look at Rio and you’ll see […] Posted in Rio

Published on November 29, 2013

Related stories

January 7, 2020

Porto: State of the Stomach 2020

Porto | By Cláudia Brandão
PortoLunch at Casa Guedes is one of our favorite culinary rituals in Porto: After snagging a seat at the bar during the midday rush, we sit, mesmerized, as Mr. Cesar nimbly cuts slices of roasted pork shank, then places them on bread and moistens it all with his secret sauce. While not the only item…
November 27, 2017

Emice’nin Yeri: Black Sea Soul Food

Istanbul | By Zamira Skalkottas
IstanbulEveryone seems to feel at ease in Emice’nin Yeri. It’s the kind of place where workers come after their shifts, families and couples dine, single men drink their tea and watch football matches on the TV, and women too are comfortable eating alone. But it’s not just a welcoming place – Emice’nin Yeri also happens…
May 20, 2014

Santa Filomena: Casually Serious, Seriously Casual

Rio | By Taylor Barnes
RioLike the classic optical illusion of the faces and the vase, look at Rio and you’ll see two sharply contrasting versions. First is the seemingly easygoing beach city of rubber sandals and gushy greetings as insincere as they are well intentioned. (“Passa lá em casa!” “Come by my home!” The carioca will actually be quite…